There’s hardly anything more timeless than pairing jeans with a white T-shirt. While this simple combo works with almost any type of shoe, classic outfits truly shine when styled with equally classic footwear. Actress Molly Gordon clearly understands this.

While promoting her new film Oh, Hi! in New York City last week, she made an appearance on The Late Show With Stephen Colbert wearing a white T-shirt—showing support for the host—along with relaxed Levi’s jeans. Instead of opting for casual shoes, she elevated the look with black pointed-toe pumps, arguably the most refined choice possible.

Some outfits completely transform based on the shoes worn with them, and jeans with a white tee is a perfect example. Had Gordon chosen sneakers, ballet flats, or flip-flops, the look would’ve felt far more casual. But stylish dressers know the power of the right shoe, and her choice resulted in a polished, paparazzi-ready ensemble. If you’re looking to invest in a versatile pair of black pointed-toe pumps to wear with jeans, a tee, and beyond, you’ll find plenty of great options worth considering.